What is sleep? How does the brain sleep? Why do we sleep?
In his latest STIAS project, Carlos Ibáñez of the Department of Neuroscience at the Karolinska Institute is delving into the fascinating world of sleep. His project explores the intersection of minimalist music and the neurobiology of sleep, drawing inspiration from the composition SLEEP by post-minimalist German-British composer Max Richter. SLEEP is an eight-and-a-half-hour composition for piano, string ensemble, organ, soprano vocals, synthesisers and electronics that premiered in 2015. The performance is a cross between a concert and an installation. Audiences are provided with beds to sleep on during the performance. For SLEEP, Richter drew inspiration from our knowledge of sleep neurobiology.
What is sleep?
Sleep is three things.
"It’s behaviour. It’s also a physiological process in which there is lowered muscle tone, including Rapid Eye Movement (REM) atonia so that you don’t act out your dreams; and in which there are no overt displays of responsivity,” explained Ibáñez. “It’s easily reversible and adheres to a reliable, timed pattern across 24 hours – known as the circadian rhythm. And, finally, it’s a brain state.”
Brain activity during sleep is studied by recording electrical signals with electrodes placed on the scalp (EEG), each recording the summed activity of thousands of neurons. Ibáñez explained that the electrical hallmark of full wakefulness is fast-frequency, chaotic brainwave activity, while during sleep neuronal activity becomes progressively more coordinated (waves). This has enabled us to measure the frequency in Hertz of waves per second, giving a clear indication of brainwave speed during different sleep stages.
“Our sleep architecture occurs in five cycles of 90 minutes each across the night,” he explained. “We experience each stage in each cycle. As the cycles progress, the length of REM sleep is longer, with the last cycle having the longest REM with vivid dreams lasting about an hour.”
Different mammals sleep for different periods – examples include elephants who sleep for two hours, dogs for 13 hours and humans for seven hours. “Humans are among the shortest; predators sleep longer than prey and generally larger animals sleep for shorter periods, but this is generalising,” said Ibáñez. “We think only mammals and some birds dream.”
And some animals sleep using only one side of their brain at a time.
“Uni-hemispheric Non-REM (slow-wave) sleep may occur in some birds, reptiles and cetaceans (whales, dolphins and porpoises),” said Ibáñez. “Otherwise, they would fall from the sky or drown in the sea. Cetaceans are conscious breathers − they must actively decide to surface and take a breath. Full bi-hemispheric unconsciousness would cause them to choke or drown. They are generally not thought to have REM sleep.”
Using MRI images, he showed the brain activities during different sleep stages. In REM sleep, dreaming there is strong activation of visual, motor, emotional and autobiographical memory regions and deactivation of the regions that control rational thought (lateral prefrontal cortex) – the CEO regions of the brain that distinguish illusion from reality. “However, the phenomenon of lucid dreaming is also possible – dream awareness that may include volitional control of dream content.”
In slow-wave NREM sleep – deep sleep brainwaves are generated in the frontal lobes and mostly travel from the front to the back in a meticulously coordinated way. “According to Matthew Walker (in his book Why We Sleep), the slowest brainwaves of NREM sleep resemble those of patients under anaesthesia or in certain forms of coma. These steady, slow NREM brainwaves can open communication possibilities between distant regions of the brain, allowing them to send and receive from different repositories of stored experience.”
The brain goes to sleep by a process controlled by two drives − the S (sleep) drive is caused by accumulation of adenosine (a naturally occurring nucleoside found in all our cells that acts as a signalling molecule influencing sleep, blood flow and heart rhythm) and process C – the circadian wave drive mainly driven by orexin (a neuropeptide) and acetylcholine (a neurotransmitter) that tells you when to sleep and when to wake. The urge to sleep is the distance between the two drive curves.
And why does caffeine keep us awake? Because it blocks the adenosine receptors and stops adenosine from rising in the brain. Caffeine is eventually degraded by the liver enzyme CYP1A2. This enzyme is polymorphic in humans, which explains our differing susceptibility to caffeine.
Why do we sleep?
“Why questions in biology are always the trickiest,” said Ibáñez. “The evolutionary argument is that we wouldn’t give up all the things we miss unless it serves a crucial primordial function. Well, it serves not one but three important functions. Sleep is restorative. Sleep plays a role in information processing – emotional acuity, learning and memory consolidation and creativity. And sleep (dreaming specifically) may allow mental-virtual reality simulations. It would be nice to think this is a rehearsal for potential threats, but it’s probably only a nice thought.”
He explained that NREM sleep allows an energy reset, clearing of toxins, synaptic downscaling and prevention of cognitive decline. NREM also aids in long-term memory consolidation – the brainwaves move memory packets from the hippocampus to more permanent storage in the neocortex. “Mild electrical stimulation during NREM almost doubles the number of facts individuals can recall the next day,” said Ibáñez. “And, according to Walker, auditory tones synchronised with brainwaves have been shown to enhance memory by 40 per cent.”
REM sleep recalibrates and fine-tunes the emotional circuits of the brain; regions of the brain that decode emotional signals become reactivated; and noradrenaline, a stress-related neurotransmitter, is shut off. “REM sleep dissolves the painful emotional charge that wraps around upsetting memories. It’s also been found that prazosin (used to reduce blood pressure) reduces the noradrenergic fear-arousal state that can turn REM dreaming into a nightmare, particularly in people with PTSD.”
“REM sleep aids problem-solving and creativity – the brain becomes actively biased towards seeking out distant, non-obvious links between sets of information. REM sleep dreaming also takes what we learn in one experience setting and applies it to others stored in memory. These collisions spark new creative insights as novel links are forged between unrelated pieces of information.”
How do we know this?
Scientists compare people who get normal sleep with those whose sleep is disrupted and then test what happens to memory, mood, attention and emotional regulation. They also measure brain activity in sleep and enhance or interrupt specific sleep rhythms. “If disrupting a particular aspect impairs and enhancing it improves the function, we have evidence that the sleep process is contributing.”
Ibáñez’s own sleep-deprivation studies on mice show that deprivation impaired major mechanisms of associated learning. “Mutant mice that lacked the p75 neurotrophin receptor did not show these memory impairments and were protected from sleep deprivation,” he said. “Sleep deprivation is an active process; it needs certain genes to be functional for the degradation of memory to occur.”
What about the music?
In a seminar peppered with excerpts from the 10-year celebration of SLEEP, Ibáñez explained how it had inspired his interest: “Richter describes it as an eight-hour lullaby meant to be listened to at night. Lullabies are a very old tradition, and the music draws from that. It results in all kinds of responses. The beat rate in the different pieces of the composition matches frequencies in the slow waves of brain activity during NREM sleep. Most of the pitches are in the low register. Following a long tradition of lullabies, starting with Bach’s Goldberg variations, SLEEP is a tour-de-force in contemporary music, not least for the performers.”
Article: Michelle Galloway
Picture: Ignus Dreyer, SCPS Photos

